SeattleDave.com

Where to Stay in New York City: Best Areas & Hotels

By Seattle Dave • Updated: January 28, 2026

My Favorite Hotels in NYC

• 5-star: Mandarin
• 4-star: ArcherPendry
• 3-star: citizenM
• For families: AKA
• For couples: LibraryCrosby
• Times Square: Marriott
• Central Park: Pierre
• Penn Station: Renaissance
• Grand Central: Library
• Empire State Bldg: Langham
• Lower Manhattan: Crosby
• Financial District: Beekman

My favorite places to stay in NYC.
1. Mandarin Oriental • 2. Pierre • 3. citizenM • 4. Marriott • 5. Pendry • 6. Renaissance • 7. Archer • 8. Langham • 9. Library • 10. Chelsea • 11. Barrière Fouquet’s • 12. Crosby St. • 13. Greenwich • 14. Beekman • 15. Nine Orchard

Me and my wife in New York City.

My wife and I in Washington Square Park in NYC.

Best luxury place to stay in New York City.

The view of Central Park from the Mandarin Oriental – my favorite hotel in New York City.

Mid-range hotel near Times Square in NYC.

citizenM hotel – trendy yet affordable hotel near Times Square.

Boutique hotel in Midtown Manhattan.

The Library – my favorite Midtown hotel.

Best Neighborhood for a First-Time Visitor

For first-time visitors to New York City, I strongly recommend staying in or near Midtown Manhattan, specifically the area encompassing Times Square and the Theater District (roughly 42nd St to 50th St). After dozens of stays across Manhattan, this is still where I recommend first-timers start. While the area is undeniably crowded and touristy, its convenience is unbeatable.

The Tradeoff: You will deal with constant crowds, noise, and higher prices. However, on a first trip, the ability to walk to major sights and catch any subway line outweighs the negatives. Tip: For a slightly calmer experience, choose a hotel west of 7th Avenue or north of 48th Street, where the neon lights fade but the convenience remains.

Me and my wife in New York City.

My wife and I during a walk along the High Line in New York City.

Why Midtown is the Best Base

  • Location & Walkability: You are in the center of the action. Iconic sights like Times Square, Rockefeller Center, Fifth Avenue, Bryant Park, and the New York Public Library are all within a 10-minute walk.
  • Broadway: The Theater District is on your doorstep. This is crucial if you plan to see a show, as getting a taxi after a performance is difficult. Walking home is a luxury.
  • Transit Connectivity: The Times Square-42nd St station is the busiest transport hub in the city. With access to the 1, 2, 3, 7, N, Q, R, S, and W trains, you can reach any part of the city without complicated transfers. Note: It is a massive station; some transfers require walking long underground tunnels, but signs are clear.
  • Dining: While the immediate area is filled with chains, you are a short walk from Hell’s Kitchen (9th Ave), which offers hundreds of authentic, high-quality restaurants.
  • Safety & Noise: The constant foot traffic, lighting, and visible police presence can feel reassuring for first-time visitors, especially at night. Warning: It is loud. Light sleepers should request a room on a high floor or facing an interior courtyard.
Good hotel near Times Square and subway station.

The Sheraton Times Square is a huge hotel with dated rooms and average reviews. However, the location is fantastic for sightseeing: in the Theater District, a short walk to Central Park, and with a subway entrance (visible here) directly beside the hotel. Book it for the convenience, not the luxury.

Top Hotels in Midtown (Times Square/Theater District):

Marriott MarquisSheraton Times SquareAKA Times SquareMargaritaville Times SquarecitizenMHilton Garden Inn Times Square CentralRiu Plaza Times SquarePod Times SquareLUMA HotelEdison Times SquareWestin at Times SquareAndaz 5th Avenue

Understanding the Layout

The Five Boroughs

  • Manhattan: The long, narrow island that most first-time visitors identify as “New York City.” Most visitors will spend 90% of their time here, with perhaps a short trip to Brooklyn.
  • Brooklyn: Located across the East River via the Brooklyn Bridge. It is massive, diverse, and offers the best skyline views of Manhattan.
  • Queens: Home to both major airports (JFK and LaGuardia) and the most ethnically diverse neighborhoods in the world.
  • The Bronx: Located north of Manhattan; home to Yankee Stadium and the Bronx Zoo.
  • Staten Island: Reached by a free ferry from Downtown Manhattan. It is suburban and quiet.

Manhattan: The Three Main Sections

  • Downtown (South of 14th St): The oldest part of the city. Includes the Financial District, SoHo, Greenwich Village, and Tribeca. The streets here are winding and do not follow the grid, so navigation relies more on landmarks and maps than street numbers.
  • Midtown (14th St to 59th St): The heart of the city. Home to the Empire State Building, Times Square, and Grand Central. Characterized by skyscrapers and a dense, logical grid.
  • Uptown (North of 59th St): Includes the Upper West Side, Upper East Side, and Harlem. It is more residential and flanks Central Park.

How to Navigate the Grid

  • The Logic: The grid system begins roughly above Houston Street (pronounced HOW-stun), but becomes perfect and predictable above 14th Street.
  • Avenues run North-South: They are long and numbered 1st to 12th (East to West). Fifth Avenue is the dividing line. Addresses are labeled “East” or “West” based on their position relative to Fifth Avenue.
  • Streets run East-West: They are numbered sequentially, starting from 1st Street and going up to 220th+ Street in the north.
  • Uptown vs. Downtown: These are directions, not just places. If the street numbers are getting higher, you are heading Uptown (North). If numbers are getting lower, you are heading Downtown (South).
  • Broadway: The exception. It cuts diagonally across the grid, creating major intersections where it crosses avenues (Union Square, Herald Square, Times Square, Columbus Circle).
  • Walking Scale: 20 north-south blocks equal roughly one mile. Most north-south walks feel shorter than they look; east-west walks between avenues take longer than expected.

8 Things to Know Before Booking

  • 1. Hotel Reality: Tiny Rooms & Slow Elevators
    This is the biggest shock for visitors. The average NYC hotel room is roughly 200–250 square feet – often just enough space for a queen bed (two beds are rare unless you book a double) and your suitcase. Vertical Delays: Be prepared for elevator bottlenecks. Older hotels often have slow, small elevators, while massive Midtown high-rises can have long waits during the morning rush.
  • 2. Location Beats Luxury
    In NYC, a basic hotel in a great location is far better than a luxury hotel far from the subway. A “nice” hotel in the wrong spot can add 30–40 minutes of travel time to every day. Rule of Thumb: Always check the walking distance to a major subway station (major trunk lines like the 1/2/3, A/C/E, or N/Q/R) before booking.
  • 3. The Real Cost: Taxes & Hidden Fees
    The price you see online is rarely the price you pay. NYC hotel rates are subject to state, city, and occupancy taxes that add roughly 15% to the bill. On top of that, many hotels charge mandatory “Destination Fees” (or Facility Fees) of $30–$50 per night. Always budget for this “bill shock” – it can easily add $75–$100+ per night to your total.
  • 4. Do Not Rent a Car
    A car is a liability here. Traffic is often gridlocked, and overnight parking at hotels typically costs $70 to $100 per night. The only time a rental makes sense is if you are picking it up to immediately leave the city (e.g., heading upstate). Otherwise, use the subway or Uber. New York is one of the easiest major cities in the U.S. to visit without a car.
  • 5. Street Noise is Constant
    New York never actually sleeps. Sirens, garbage trucks, and honking continue through the night. Location Matters: Rooms facing major avenues (7th Ave, Broadway, 42nd St) are significantly louder than those on side streets – even on high floors. Light sleepers should request a high floor facing an interior courtyard.
  • 6. The Subway is Faster than Taxis
    During the day, the subway is almost always the fastest way to travel. It is heavily used by locals and tourists alike and is generally safe. Taxis frequently get stuck in gridlock, turning a 15-minute trip into a 45-minute ordeal. Use OMNY (contactless payment) at the turnstile – each person must use their own card or device to get free transfers. Google Maps and Citymapper handle real-time service changes extremely well.
  • 7. Airport Transfers Strategy
    Getting from JFK or Newark to Manhattan is pricey. A taxi or Uber will often exceed $100 all-in. However, taxis make sense for families, groups of 3–4, or travelers with heavy luggage. For budget-conscious or solo travelers, the trains (LIRR from JFK or NJ Transit from Newark) are fast, reliable, and cost a fraction of a cab ride ($15–$20 per person).
  • 8. Arrival Logistics
    NYC hotels are strict about check-in times (usually 3:00 pm or 4:00 pm) and early check-in is rarely guaranteed. However, almost all hotels will store your luggage for free before check-in and after check-out, so you can drop your bags and start exploring immediately.

The Best Places to Stay in NYC

Best place to stay in Lower Manhattan.

The Beekman in Lower Manhattan.

Hotel for families in Midtown.

Our room at the AKA Times Square in Midtown. One and two bedroom apartments available. Great for families.

Hotel in Soho New York for couples and honeymooners.

Our room at the Soho Grand Hotel.

Hotel near Eataly, the Flatiron Building, Union Square Park, and Grand Central Station.

Our room at the Giraffe Hotel near Washington Square Park.

Hotel for couples in Midtown Manhattan.

Our room at the Library Hotel.

Luxury hotel on Upper West Side of Manhattan.

Our room at the Mandarin Oriental.

Trendy boutique hotel near Madison Square Garden and Hudson Yards.

Our room at the Pendry Manhattan West.

The 10 Best Neighborhoods in NYC for Tourists

1. Midtown Manhattan

Midtown Manhattan.
A map of Midtown Manhattan in New York City.

Midtown is the heart of the city, generally spanning from 34th Street to 59th Street, river to river. This is where you find the highest concentration of famous landmarks, the brightest lights, and the biggest crowds. Even after many visits to New York, Midtown remains the most efficient base I recommend for first-time visitors.

  • Best For: First-time visitors, short stays (2–4 nights), Broadway fans, and travelers who prioritize maximum convenience over local atmosphere.
  • The Tradeoff: It is intense. Expect constant crowds, noise late into the night, and smaller hotel rooms relative to the price. Tip: Avoid booking a hotel directly facing Times Square unless you are prepared for noise at all hours.
  • Why it Works: Nearly every subway line passes through here, making it the easiest base for exploring all five boroughs.

The Lay of the Land
Midtown is not monolithic. It helps to know the sub-areas:

  • Times Square / Theater District: The center of the energy. Busy, bright, and loud.
  • Bryant Park / Grand Central: Just a few blocks east, this area feels more polished, slightly calmer, and more business-focused.
  • Hudson Yards (West Midtown): Located on the far west side. It feels newer and quieter but is less walkable to the classic sights.

The Highlights

The Skyline Views
You have four major observation decks competing for your attention here:

Hudson Yards & The High Line
This modern development is the northern entry point for the High Line elevated park. Its centerpiece, the Vessel, has reopened with new floor-to-ceiling safety mesh. Note: Access is more controlled than before, and the experience is more limited than originally intended.

Luxury Update: The legendary Waldorf Astoria New York has officially reopened following a massive renovation. Be aware that it has been repositioned as a top-tier exclusive property; room counts are lower and prices are significantly higher than before.

Hotel in Times Square, New York City.

The Marriott Marquis in Times Square is as central as you can get.

2. Upper West Side & Central Park

Central Park in New York City.
A map of the Upper West Side and Central Park in Manhattan, New York City.

If Midtown is where you go to see the sights, the Upper West Side (UWS) is where you go to live the life. Generally running from **59th Street to 110th Street**, sandwiched between **Central Park** to the east and **Riverside Park** to the west, this is a wealthy, residential, and relaxed neighborhood.

  • Best For: Families, couples seeking a quieter feel, culture lovers (opera, ballet, museums), and travelers who value parks over nightlife.
  • The Comparison: Choose this area over Midtown if you value space, greenery, and calm evenings over nonstop activity.
  • The Tradeoff: It is much quieter at night. While there are excellent restaurants and wine bars, there is very little late-night nightlife compared to downtown. Note: Getting to JFK or Newark airports typically takes longer from here than from Midtown.
  • Transit Strategy: You are served by the 1, 2, 3, B, and C trains. Tip: The 1 train runs local, while the 2 and 3 provide faster express service – look for a hotel near a 2/3 stop (like 72nd or 96th St) for the most efficient travel.

Cultural Heavyweights
Even though it is residential, the UWS packs a massive cultural punch:

Central Park Highlights
The UWS offers some of the best access to the park’s most famous spots:

  • Strawberry Fields: The “Imagine” mosaic tribute to John Lennon, located just across the street from the Dakota building where he lived.
  • The Lake & Bow Bridge: The most romantic spot in the park. You can rent rowboats at the Loeb Boathouse.
  • Bethesda Terrace: The iconic fountain and arcade often seen in movies.
  • Delacorte Theater: Home to the beloved (and free) Shakespeare in the Park. Note: Performances run in the summer only and tickets are in extremely high demand.

The Food Scene
Unlike Midtown’s chains, this area is defined by local institutions.

  • Levain Bakery: Famous for their massive, gooey chocolate chip walnut cookies. Expect a line.
  • Zabar’s: A legendary gourmet grocery store. The ultimate spot to grab bagels, smoked fish, and coffee for a park picnic.
  • Jacob’s Pickles: A crowd favorite for massive portions of Southern comfort food, biscuits, and beer. Great for dinner.
English tea at Mandarin Oriental.

Afternoon tea at MO Lounge in the Mandarin Oriental is an absolute delight.

3. Upper East Side

Upper East Side in NYC.
A map of the Upper East Side in Manhattan, New York City.

Known for “Old Money,” high fashion, and incredible art, the Upper East Side (UES) stretches generally from **59th to 96th Streets** (though locals consider **Yorkville** up to 110th Street part of the mix), between Central Park and the East River. It is polished, clean, and significantly quieter than Midtown.

  • Best For: Art lovers, luxury travelers, families, and visitors who prioritize museums and calm evenings over nightlife.
  • The Comparison: Choose the Upper East Side over the Upper West Side if you care more about art museums and luxury shopping than riverside walks and casual dining.
  • The Tradeoff: It can feel stuffy and expensive. Nightlife is subdued – mostly upscale bars and quiet lounges rather than clubs. Note: While subway access has improved, travel to Downtown attractions (SoHo, World Trade Center) takes longer than from the West Side.
  • Transit Update: The **Q Train** (Second Avenue Subway) now provides fast, modern service down the east side, dramatically improving convenience for hotels east of Lexington Avenue.

The “Two” Neighborhoods
To understand the UES, you must distinguish between west and east:

  • West of Lexington Ave: The classic “Gossip Girl” area. Expect townhouses, doormen, designer boutiques, and very quiet nights.
  • East of Lexington Ave (Yorkville): Younger and more residential. This area offers livelier dining, a local vibe, and better value. Tip: For hotel deals, look east of Third Avenue near Q-line stations.

Museum Mile (Fifth Avenue)
This is one of the densest concentrations of culture in the world.

The Food Scene
While known for fine dining, there is variety if you know where to look.

  • JG Melon: A cash-only institution on 3rd Ave famous for its burgers and preppy vibe.
  • Bemelmans Bar: Located in the Carlyle Hotel, this is the city’s most iconic upscale jazz bar. Expensive, but magical.
  • Up Thai: A popular, stylish spot on 2nd Avenue that represents the excellent, more casual dining scene found in Yorkville.
The Carlyle Hotel in New York.

The Carlyle Hotel on New York’s Upper East Side.

4. Tribeca & SoHo

SOHO district in NYC.
A map of Tribeca and SoHo on Manhattan in New York City.

These two neighborhoods sit side-by-side but offer completely different experiences. **SoHo** (South of Houston) runs from Houston St south to Canal St and is a high-energy, open-air shopping district. **Tribeca** (Triangle Below Canal) lies south of Canal St, stretching toward the World Trade Center, and is an ultra-wealthy, quiet residential enclave.

  • Best For: Fashion lovers, foodies, luxury travelers, and repeat visitors who want a stylish, downtown vibe rather than classic sightseeing convenience.
  • The Decision Shortcut: Choose SoHo if you want energy, shopping, and street life right outside your door. Choose Tribeca if you want space, quiet, and a celebrity-studded residential feel.
  • The Tradeoff: This is one of Manhattan’s priciest areas. Hotel rooms are often smaller and more expensive than in Midtown, with fewer family-friendly options. Note: Subway access is solid but spread out – expect a short walk to stations rather than a major hub outside your door.
  • Luggage Warning: Both neighborhoods feature historic cobblestone streets. They are charming but a nightmare for rolling suitcases. If arriving with luggage, take a taxi or Uber directly to your hotel door rather than walking from the subway.

SoHo Highlights: Shopping & Architecture
Most people come here to shop, but the area itself is the attraction.

  • Cast-Iron Historic District: SoHo contains the world’s largest collection of cast-iron buildings. The intricate facades along Greene and Mercer Streets are stunning.
  • Shopping: While it was once known for indie boutiques, SoHo is now dominated by major global brands (Nike, Zara, Uniqlo) and high-end luxury designers. It gets incredibly crowded on weekends.
  • Interactive Museums: Home to the Museum of Ice Cream (famous for its sprinkle pool) and the nearby Color Factory. These are designed specifically for social media – fun for teens, but skip them if you want traditional culture.

Tribeca Highlights: Architecture & Atmosphere
Tribeca is about atmosphere, fine dining, and hidden wealth.

  • “Ghostbusters” Firehouse: The working fire station (Hook & Ladder 8) on North Moore Street was the HQ in the movies. A popular photo op.
  • 56 Leonard: Known as the “Jenga Building,” this cantilevered glass skyscraper is a modern architectural marvel towering over the low-rise district.
  • Museums: The Jackie Robinson Museum (dedicated to the baseball legend) and the New York City Fire Museum are located here.

The Food Scene
Dining here is excellent but expensive – expect a scene.

  • Balthazar (SoHo): A bustling French brasserie that has been the “place to be” for decades. Essential for brunch, but book far in advance.
  • Locanda Verde (Tribeca): A warm, bustling Italian taverna co-owned by Robert De Niro. Great energy and incredible food.
  • The Odeon (Tribeca): A classic Art Deco cafeteria/bistro that defines the Tribeca vibe.
  • Dominique Ansel Bakery (SoHo): Home of the Cronut. The line starts early, but their other pastries (like the DKA) are just as good and easier to get.
Greenwich Hotel in TriBeca.

The excellent Greenwich Hotel in Tribeca.

5. East Village

East Village in NYC.
A map of the East Village in New York City.

Once a center of punk rock and counterculture, the East Village (Houston St to 14th St, between Bowery and the East River) is now the city’s most vibrant dining and nightlife district. It feels raw and lived-in rather than polished.

  • Best For: Foodies, nightlife lovers, students, and travelers who want energy and character over peace and polish.
  • The Comparison: Choose this over SoHo or Tribeca if nightlife, diversity, and late-night energy matter more to you than luxury and quiet.
  • The Tradeoff: It can be loud and gritty. Many buildings are old walk-ups (no elevators). Sleep Tip: If you value sleep, choose a hotel on a quieter side street rather than directly above the bars on the main avenues.
  • Transit Reality: Subway access is uneven. Areas near Astor Place and Union Square are well-connected, but if you stay east of 1st Avenue (Alphabet City), you are a long walk from the train. Pro Tip: The M14 Crosstown bus is often the fastest way to get across town from here.

Highlights & Culture

  • Tompkins Square Park: The heart of the neighborhood. It’s a perfect spot for people-watching, grabbing a coffee, and soaking in the local dog-run culture.
  • Vintage Shopping: The area is packed with excellent vintage and thrift stores, particularly around 9th Street and St. Mark’s Place.
  • “Little Ukraine”: The neighborhood has deep Ukrainian roots. Visit the Ukrainian Museum or stop by St. George Ukrainian Catholic Church on 7th Street.

The Food & Drink Scene
This is arguably the best dining neighborhood in Manhattan.

  • Veselka: A near-24-hour Ukrainian diner that is a neighborhood icon. You must try the borscht and pierogi. It draws everyone from party-goers at 3 AM to families at noon.
  • Superiority Burger: A cult-favorite vegetarian spot (located in the old Odessa diner space) that serves incredible food with a fun, retro vibe.
  • McSorley’s Old Ale House: Established in 1854, this is America’s oldest Irish pub. The floor is covered in sawdust, they only serve two types of beer (Light or Dark), and the history is palpable.
  • Speakeasies: The area is famous for hidden cocktail bars. Please Don’t Tell (PDT) (entered through a phone booth in a hot dog shop) and Death & Co are legends of the craft cocktail world.
The Bowery Hotel in New York's East Village.

The Bowery is one of the best of the East Village’s few hotel options.

6. Greenwich Village (West Village) & Meatpacking District

Washington Square Park in New York City.
A map of Greenwich Village and the Meatpacking District in New York City.

This is the New York you see in movies: leafy streets, charming 19th-century brownstones, and intimate cafes. **Greenwich Village** generally spans from **Houston St to 14th St**, between Broadway and the Hudson River. *Note: Technically, the “West Village” is just the western portion (west of 7th Ave), but most visitors use the terms interchangeably.*

Just to the northwest lies the **Meatpacking District**, a former industrial zone turned high-gloss nightlife and fashion hub.

  • Best For: Romantics, food lovers, culture seekers, and travelers who value charm and walkability over transit efficiency.
  • The Comparison: Choose this over the East Village if you want a cleaner, more polished experience. Choose it over SoHo if you prefer cozy cafes to big-brand shopping.
  • The Tradeoff: It is one of Manhattan’s most expensive areas. Hotel options are scarce – book early, or consider staying just north in Chelsea for better availability.
  • Noise Reality: Village side streets are often very quiet at night, while areas near Bleecker Street stay lively. Meatpacking Warning: The Meatpacking District is loud, clubby, and crowded with partygoers Thursday through Saturday nights.
  • Navigation Warning: The grid system does not exist here. Streets curve, intersect at odd angles, and sometimes cross themselves (W 4th St crosses W 10th St). You will get lost – use your phone map.

Village Highlights & History

  • Washington Square Park: The heart of the neighborhood and NYU’s “campus.” It is always alive with musicians, chess players, and protesters. The marble Arch is iconic.
  • Pop Culture Pilgrimage: Crowds still flock to the corner of Bedford and Grove Streets to see the “Friends” apartment exterior. Nearby at 66 Perry Street is “Carrie Bradshaw’s Apartment.” Tip: These are private homes; visit early in the morning to avoid crowds and be respectful.
  • LGBTQ History: The Stonewall Inn is a working bar and a National Monument marking the birthplace of the modern gay rights movement. The area is especially vibrant during Pride Month (June).

Meatpacking & Art
Located roughly between 14th Street and Gansevoort Street, west of 9th Ave.

  • The Whitney Museum: The Whitney Museum of American Art is a stunning modern building dedicated to 20th and 21st-century American art. Its outdoor terraces offer incredible views.
  • The High Line: The Whitney marks the southern entrance to The High Line, the famous elevated park built on old rail tracks.

Dining & Entertainment
This is a neighborhood for wandering and grazing.

  • Via Carota: A rustic Italian trattoria that is arguably the most beloved “local” restaurant in the neighborhood right now. Walk-in only, so go early.
  • Classic Cafes: Caffe Reggio (home of the first cappuccino in the US) serves history in a cup. Magnolia Bakery still draws lines for its banana pudding and cupcakes.
  • Live Entertainment: The Village Vanguard is the holy grail of jazz clubs (book ahead). The Comedy Cellar is the city’s most famous stand-up venue – reservations are essential.
  • Joe’s Pizza: Located on Carmine Street, this is widely considered the quintessential New York street slice.
Washington Square Park Hotel in New York City.

The historic Washington Square Hotel is ideally located for enjoying the bars and entertainment venues of the West Village.

7. Chelsea

Chelsea in New York City.
A map of the Chelsea neighborhood in New York City.

Chelsea is one of the best all-around bases in Manhattan if you want central access without the chaos of Times Square. Spanning generally **west of 6th Avenue**, from **14th Street to 30th Street**, it bridges the charm of the Village and the bustle of Midtown.

  • Best For: Art lovers, foodies, LGBTQ+ travelers, and visitors who want a central location that feels cooler and less “touristy” than Midtown.
  • Not Ideal For: Travelers seeking “Old New York” quiet charm or a strictly residential feel.
  • The Tradeoff: Hotel prices are generally lower than the West Village but higher than Midtown South. Location Warning: The blocks closest to Penn Station (around 7th–8th Ave and 30th–34th St) are busier, noisier, and much grittier than central or southern Chelsea.
  • Transit Strategy: Chelsea is well-connected (A/C/E, 1/2/3, F/M trains), making it a convenient base. Note: Stations are spread out, so expect short walks to the subway rather than a single central hub outside your door.
  • Hotel Tip: For the best balance of quiet and convenience, look for hotels between **20th and 26th Streets**, west of 7th Avenue.

The High Line Corridor
The western edge of Chelsea has been transformed by The High Line, an elevated rail line turned public park running from Gansevoort St to 34th St.

  • Timing Tip: The park is extremely popular. Visit early in the morning or on weekdays to avoid the “conga line” of tourists.
  • Chelsea Market: An enormous indoor food hall located in the old Nabisco factory. It is packed with tourists but worth a visit for tacos at Los Tacos No. 1 or souvenirs at Pearl River Mart.
  • Little Island: Located at Pier 55, this “floating” park sits on unique concrete tulip-pot structures. It’s a stunning spot for sunset views. Note: Programming and performances are seasonal, peaking from late spring through fall.

The Art District
West Chelsea (roughly 19th to 28th Streets, between 10th and 11th Avenues) is the center of the contemporary art world.

  • Gallery Hopping: Dozens of world-class galleries occupy converted warehouses here. David Zwirner, Gagosian, and Hauser & Wirth often host museum-quality exhibitions that are completely free to enter. Thursday nights are traditionally “opening nights.”

Food & Lifestyle

  • Cookshop: A bustling farm-to-table restaurant on 10th Avenue. It is a neighborhood staple for brunch and dinner.
  • Chelsea Flea: A fantastic outdoor vintage market open on weekends on W 25th St. Great for finding unique NYC treasures.
  • Nightlife: Lively but more dispersed than the nearby Meatpacking District. Expect busy bars and speakeasies rather than mega-clubs.

Note: The Rubin Museum of Art, formerly a neighborhood staple, closed its physical space in late 2024 to become a “museum without walls.”

Hotel Chelsea in NYC.

The iconic Hotel Chelsea is the historic stomping ground of forward-thinking celebrities ranging from Mark Twain to Janis Joplin to Robert Mapplethorpe.

8. Lower Manhattan & the Financial District (FiDi)

911 Memorial in Lower Manhattan.
A map of Lower Manhattan & the Financial District in New York City.

Lower Manhattan generally includes the **Financial District (FiDi)**, the **World Trade Center** area, **Battery Park**, and the **Seaport**. It is a neighborhood of stark contrasts: narrow colonial streets overshadowed by massive skyscrapers, and the solemnity of the 9/11 Memorial just blocks from the exuberant dining scene at the Seaport.

  • Best For: History buffs, families, business travelers, and value-seekers on weekends. Not Ideal For: Nightlife-focused travelers or those wanting late-night dining options.
  • The Comparison: Choose this over Midtown if you want history, waterfront walks, and better weekend hotel value instead of constant crowds.
  • The Tradeoff: Because the area is primarily commercial, nightlife and casual dining thin out significantly after business hours. Vibe Check: Weekdays are busy and corporate; weekends are calm, quiet, and residential.
  • Insider Tip: This is often the best value area for hotels on weekends. Rates drop significantly Friday through Sunday when the corporate crowd leaves. Recommendation: Look near Fulton Street or the WTC area for the best balance of transit access and atmosphere.
  • Transit Hub: The Fulton Center and nearby stations connect almost every major subway line, making Downtown one of the easiest places to get around from.

World Trade Center & The Oculus
This area has been completely rebuilt into a modern district of commerce and remembrance.

  • 9/11 Memorial & Museum: The twin reflecting pools are free to visit and incredibly moving. The underground museum is essential viewing but emotionally heavy – allocate at least two hours.
  • One World Observatory: Located at the top of One World Trade Center. The views are expansive, though many travelers prefer Midtown decks (like Top of the Rock) for seeing the entire skyline at once.
  • The Oculus: Santiago Calatrava’s white, skeletal transportation hub is an architectural marvel. It houses a massive shopping mall (skewing toward high-end brands) and connects you to the subway and PATH trains.

Wall Street & Historic Sights

  • The Statues: The famous Charging Bull stands at Bowling Green. The Fearless Girl statue now stands facing the New York Stock Exchange on Broad Street. Note: The area is heavily crowded with tourists during trading hours.
  • History: Visit Trinity Church (where Alexander Hamilton is buried), St. Paul’s Chapel (Manhattan’s oldest church), and the African Burial Ground Monument.
  • Smithsonian’s National Museum of the American Indian: Located in the stunning historic Custom House at Bowling Green. It is free and often overlooked.

The Waterfront: Ferries & The Seaport

  • Battery Park: The departure point for the Statue of Liberty and Ellis Island ferries. Warning: Official ferries depart only from inside the park (Statue City Cruises). Ignore the aggressive ticket sellers on the street outside the park – they sell overpriced “tours” that do not land on the island.
  • Seaport District: A revitalized area that feels more like a destination than a neighborhood. It features cobblestone streets, historic ships, Pier 17 (rooftop concerts), and the Tin Building, a luxury food hall by Jean-Georges Vongerichten.
  • Stone Street: A historic, cobblestone alley packed with pubs and restaurants. In warm weather, the outdoor seating here is one of the best vibes in the city.
Hotel in Lower Manhattan.

The 5-star Wall Street Hotel.

9. Lower East Side, Chinatown & Nolita

Popular spot in Lower East Side.
A map of the Lower East Side, including Nolita, Chinatown, and Little Italy in New York City.

This section of the city offers a fascinating collision of immigrant history, gritty nightlife, and high-end fashion. While they bleed into each other, the boundaries matter: **Chinatown** is south of Canal St; the **Lower East Side (LES)** is north of Canal and east of the Bowery; **Nolita** is north of Little Italy and west of the Bowery.

  • Best For: Foodies, history buffs, nightlife lovers, and travelers who want to see the “melting pot” history of New York.
  • Not Ideal For: Light sleepers, families with strollers (sidewalks are narrow and crowded), or travelers seeking quiet evenings.
  • The Comparison: Compared to the East Village, the Lower East Side feels rougher, louder, and more driven by late-night clubs than neighborhood bars.
  • The Tradeoff: It can be loud and gritty. Chinatown can feel intense for first-timers due to the sheer density of crowds, smells, and street markets. Safety Note: The area is generally safe but can feel chaotic late at night, especially on weekends.
  • Hotel Warning: Popular hotels like Public or citizenM Bowery are trendy but sit directly above major nightlife zones. For better sleep, avoid hotels directly on Delancey, Bowery, or Orchard Streets.

The Lower East Side (LES)
Historically a Jewish immigrant enclave, now a nightlife destination.

  • Tenement Museum: An absolute must-do. You visit restored apartments that tell the stories of actual families who lived there. Note: Tours are guided, last about 90 minutes, and are best for adults and older teens. Book in advance.
  • Essex Market: A historic market that moved into a slick new development (Essex Crossing). It feels more like a modern food hall than a traditional market, but the local vendors are excellent.
  • Jewish Culinary Trinity: The legends are all here. Katz’s Deli (pastrami), Russ & Daughters (appetizing/smoked fish), and Yonah Schimmel (knishes). Katz’s Rule: Do not lose the ticket they hand you at the door. You need it to pay and leave. Lost tickets incur a steep fine.

Chinatown & Little Italy

  • Chinatown Dining: This is the place for cheap, incredible eats. Warning: Many of the best spots are no-frills and cash-only. Try Nom Wah Tea Parlor for dim sum or Great NY Noodletown for late-night roast duck.
  • The Vibe: Wander Mott Street to see open-air fish markets and teeming sidewalks. It is chaotic but authentic.
  • Little Italy Reality Check: Little Italy has shrunk to basically one street (Mulberry St). It is purely a tourist zone now. It’s fun for a quick walk to see the red-sauce aesthetics, but for authentic Italian food, go elsewhere.

Nolita (“North of Little Italy”)
The blocks east of Lafayette and north of Broome Street feel completely different – charming, tree-lined, and expensive.

  • Shopping: This is one of the best neighborhoods for independent boutiques, niche perfumes, and delicate jewelry shops.
  • New Museum: A stack of white boxes on the Bowery, this museum is dedicated exclusively to contemporary art.
Hotel in Bowery neighborhood of New York City.

citizenM Bowery is a great midrange hotel on Nolita’s eastern edge.

10. Brooklyn

Brooklyn, New York City.
A map of the Brooklyn neighborhood in New York City.

Brooklyn is massive and highly varied – where you stay matters far more here than in Manhattan. If it were its own city, it would rank among the largest in the United States. For a visitor, view it as a collection of distinct “cities” connected by subway and ferry.

  • Best For: Repeat NYC visitors, families wanting space (Park Slope), and travelers prioritizing food and local vibes over famous landmarks.
  • Decision Shortcut (Where to Stay):
    • Dumbo/Brooklyn Heights: Best for views, walkability, and easy access to Manhattan.
    • Williamsburg: Best for nightlife, shopping, and a younger crowd.
    • Park Slope: Best for families and green space.
  • The Tradeoff: Travel time. Expect 20–30 minutes to Lower Manhattan and 30–45 minutes to Midtown from most neighborhoods. Safety Note: These neighborhoods are generally safe, but distances are larger and streets are much quieter late at night than in Manhattan.
  • Booking Strategy: If staying in Brooklyn, prioritize hotels within a 5-minute walk of a subway station. This saves you miles of walking over a trip.
  • Transit Tip: The NYC Ferry is fantastic for waterfront neighborhoods (Dumbo, Williamsburg), but it is not always the fastest option and does not run late at night.

Zone 1: Dumbo & Brooklyn Heights
Located directly across the East River from Lower Manhattan. This is the most “tourist-friendly” part of the borough.

  • The Views: Walk across the Brooklyn Bridge from Manhattan, then explore Brooklyn Bridge Park. It offers the single best skyline views of NYC.
  • Brooklyn Heights Promenade: A historic, elevated walkway lined with grand brownstones. It feels like a movie set.
  • Hotel Reality: Options right in Dumbo/Heights are limited and expensive. Many visitors find better value staying nearby in Downtown Brooklyn.
  • Time Out Market: A massive food hall in Dumbo located in a historic warehouse. It features some of the city’s best chefs and a rooftop bar with bridge views.

Zone 2: Williamsburg
The “cool” capital. Located north of Dumbo, this is a hub for nightlife, dining, and shopping.

  • The Vibe: Trendy, young, and busy. Bedford Avenue is the main drag. Noise Warning: Hotels near Bedford Ave can be loud late into the night, especially on weekends.
  • Smorgasburg: The biggest foodie event in the city. It operates seasonally (spring through fall) on Saturdays at Marsha P. Johnson State Park.
  • Bushwick: Just east of Williamsburg, this area is edgier and more nightlife-focused (street art, warehouse parties) but has fewer hotels and longer subway rides.

Zone 3: Brownstone Brooklyn (Park Slope & Prospect Park)
Located inland, south of Downtown Brooklyn. This is “residential” Brooklyn at its finest.

  • Best For: A quiet, local experience. Not Ideal For: Travelers who want quick access to Midtown attractions or late-night entertainment.
  • Prospect Park: Designed by the same creators as Central Park, many locals argue it is actually the better park. It is quieter and more “local,” especially on weekdays.
  • Culture: The massive Brooklyn Museum (NYC’s second largest art museum) and the stunning Brooklyn Botanic Garden are right next to the park.

Zone 4: Coney Island
Way off to the south, facing the Atlantic Ocean.

  • The Experience: A gritty, vintage seaside resort with a huge beach and the legendary Cyclone roller coaster at Luna Park.
  • Reality Check: This is strictly a seasonal day trip (May–September). It is a 45–60 minute subway ride from Manhattan and is not a practical base for sightseeing.
Hotel in Brooklyn.

The wonderful Box House Hotel is located in Brooklyn’s Greenpoint neighborhood.

More New York City Neighborhoods

These neighborhoods are excellent alternatives for repeat visitors, longer stays, or travelers prioritizing food, culture, or value over classic sightseeing convenience. Booking Strategy: If staying outside Manhattan, prioritize hotels within a short walk of an express subway line to minimize travel time.

  • NoMad, Flatiron & Gramercy Park: Located just south of Midtown, these neighborhoods have transformed into trendy zones. Best For: A central base with excellent dining. NoMad (roughly 23rd–28th St) is a major hotel hub, home to the National Museum of Mathematics and the Museum of Sex. Flatiron (around 23rd St & Broadway) is anchored by the iconic building and Eataly. To the east, Gramercy Park is exclusive and quiet. Reality Check: Unless you have a key, you cannot enter Gramercy Park itself; the appeal is the surrounding calm. Top Hotels: Ritz-Carlton NoMad, New York EDITION, and Virgin New York City.
  • Harlem & Washington Heights: Manhattan north of Central Park is dominated by Harlem, the historic center of Black culture. Best For: History, culture, and architecture. Transit Note: These areas are served by express subway lines (A, D, 2, 3), making Midtown access faster than from many parts of Brooklyn. Highlights include the legendary Apollo Theater, soul food at Sylvia’s or Red Rooster, and gospel at Abyssinian Baptist Church. Etiquette Tip: If attending gospel, dress respectfully, arrive early, and confirm visitors are welcome. Further north, Washington Heights is home to The Met Cloisters. Planning Note: The Cloisters are spectacular but feel like a half-day excursion due to the distance. Hotels: Aloft Harlem and Renaissance New York Harlem.
  • Queens: Often overlooked, Queens offers the most authentic food scene in the city. Best For: Value hotels and incredible food. Long Island City (LIC) is the main base; it is just one stop from Midtown on several lines and has dozens of new hotels. Foodie Tip: Take the 7 train to Jackson Heights (Roosevelt Ave between 74th and 82nd St) to experience the most diverse dining neighborhood on earth. Sports fans head to Flushing Meadows for Citi Field and the US Open. Top Hotels (LIC): Aloft Long Island City and The Modernist.
  • The Bronx: Best For: Daytime attractions. Most visitors explore the Bronx as a day trip rather than a base. The Bronx Zoo is world-class, and the New York Botanical Garden is spectacular year-round. Baseball fans flock to Yankee Stadium. Insider Tip: For real Italian food, skip Little Italy in Manhattan and head to Arthur Avenue in the Belmont section of the Bronx. It is authentic, delicious, and devoid of tourist traps.

FAQ: Where to Stay in NYC

1. What is the best, most central area to stay in NYC for first-time visitors and sightseeing?

  • For the vast majority of first-time visitors, Midtown Manhattan is the most logical base. It is the geographical and practical center of the city, offering unbeatable convenience.
  • The “Why”: Staying here maximizes your sightseeing time and minimizes navigation stress. You are within walking distance of iconic attractions like Times Square, Rockefeller Center, St. Patrick’s Cathedral, MoMA, and the Broadway Theater District.
  • Transit Hub: It is the city’s primary transportation nexus. Major subway lines converge at 42nd Street (Times Square and Grand Central), allowing you to reach Uptown, Downtown, or Brooklyn without complicated transfers.
  • Where in Midtown?:
    • Theater District: Stay here for the classic “New York” energy, bright lights, and immediate access to Broadway shows.
    • Midtown East / Grand Central: Choose this area for a slightly calmer, more professional atmosphere near Summit One Vanderbilt and the Chrysler Building.
    • Central Park South: Best for luxury travelers who want high-end shopping on Fifth Avenue and immediate access to the park.
  • Strategy Tip: Map out your top 10 “must-see” sights. If they are scattered across the city, Midtown is the most efficient hub to reach them all. If they are heavily clustered in Lower Manhattan (9/11 Memorial, Statue of Liberty, Wall Street), consider staying in the Financial District or Tribeca instead.
  • The Trade-off: Midtown is undeniably crowded and touristy. It lacks a “local” neighborhood feel. If you want character without sacrificing too much convenience, the Upper West Side (residential, family-friendly) and Greenwich Village (historic, foodie paradise) are excellent alternatives.
Hotel in Times Square.

The Margaritaville Times Square – has the only outdoor year-round (heated) pool near Times Square.

2. What are the safest neighborhoods to stay in New York City?

  • New York City is statistically one of the safest large cities in the US. However, you must use standard “city smarts”: be aware of your surroundings and keep valuables secure.
  • Subway Safety: This is the top concern for visitors. Ride in the middle cars (where the conductor is located) or the very first car. Never enter an empty subway car, even if the train is crowded. It is empty for a reason (usually a broken A/C or an unbearable smell).
  • Upper West Side: The best mix of safety and “real” New York life. It is highly residential, filled with families, and busy with locals day and night.
  • Upper East Side: Very affluent, quiet, and secure. It can feel a bit sleepy at night, but it is home to Museum Mile and is very comfortable for solo travelers.
  • Greenwich Village: One of the safest spots for nightlife. The high concentration of NYU students, locals, and diners provides constant “eyes on the street” until very late.
  • Battery Park City: A planned community in Lower Manhattan that feels like a quiet suburb. It is arguably the safest precinct in Manhattan, though it can feel isolated and empty after dark.
  • Midtown: Safe due to saturation. The intense density of tourists and corporate workers means there is a constant, visible police presence, specifically near Times Square and Grand Central.
  • SoHo & Tribeca: Upscale and safe. SoHo remains busy with shoppers into the evening, while Tribeca is quieter but extremely wealthy and secure.
  • General Rule: At night, stick to the avenues (which run north-south and are wide/brightly lit) rather than the darker, quieter cross-streets. Avoid walking through city parks after dark.
Staying near Madison Square Garden.

A Knicks, Liberty, or Rangers game at Madison Square Garden is a highlight of a New York visit. The best hotels near MSG are the Renaissance and Hampton Inn Madison Square Garden.

3. Should I stay in Manhattan or Brooklyn (or Queens/Bronx/Staten Island)?

  • Manhattan: Best for first-timers, short stays (under 4 nights), and theater lovers. You are within walking distance of the biggest sights. The trade-off is smaller rooms and higher prices, but the convenience is unmatched.
  • Brooklyn (Williamsburg, Dumbo, Brooklyn Heights): Best for repeat visitors, foodies, and those wanting a “cool” neighborhood vibe. Note: Prices in these prime waterfront areas now often rival Manhattan. You stay here for the atmosphere and skyline views, not necessarily to save money. Expect a 20-30 minute subway commute to Midtown.
  • Queens (Long Island City): The best value for proximity. LIC offers modern, clean hotels at significantly lower rates than Manhattan, yet you are often only one subway stop (5-10 minutes) from Grand Central or Times Square.
  • The Bronx & Staten Island: Generally not recommended for typical sightseeing due to long travel times. Best reserved for visitors with specific interests (like Yankee Stadium) or those on very tight budgets who don’t mind a 45+ minute commute.

4. What are the pros and cons of staying in Times Square?

  • Pros: You have unrivaled access to Broadway theaters and the city’s most important subway hub (connecting you to almost anywhere without a transfer). The high energy and “wow” factor of the neon lights are exactly what many first-timers imagine NYC to be. It is well-patrolled, safe, and services stay open very late.
  • Cons: It is intensely crowded (often shoulder-to-shoulder), noisy, and completely lacks authentic local character. Restaurants in the immediate vicinity are often overpriced tourist traps or chains. The constant sensory overload and flashing lights can be exhausting if you are sensitive to noise.
  • The Verdict: Stay here if you are a theater buff, have a very short trip, or want to be in the absolute center of the action. Avoid it if you prefer quiet retreats, unique local dining, or are easily overwhelmed by crowds.
The Upper West Side's Museum of Natural History in New York City.

The Upper West Side’s Museum of Natural History.

5. What is it like to stay in Greenwich Village, SoHo, the Upper West Side, or Midtown East?

  • Greenwich Village (“The Village”): Historic, bohemian, and incredibly charming. It features leafy streets, beautiful brownstones, and legendary jazz clubs like the Village Vanguard. Hotels here are rare and expensive, but it is the best neighborhood for walking, “date night” dining, and a true local feel.
  • SoHo: The center of NYC fashion and cast-iron architecture. It is a shopper’s paradise by day but can be expensive. Note: Many streets are cobblestoned, which looks beautiful but is a nightmare for rolling suitcases and high heels.
  • Upper West Side: Relaxed, residential, and cultured. Nestled between Central Park and Riverside Park, it is the top choice for families. You have easy access to the American Museum of Natural History and express subway trains (1, 2, 3) that get you to Times Square in minutes.
  • Midtown East: Professional and more sedate than the Times Square side. Home to Grand Central Terminal and the Chrysler Building, it offers excellent transit connections. Tip: As a business district, you can often find better hotel rates here on weekends when the corporate crowd goes home.

6. Where can I find the best boutique hotels in NYC?

  • Greenwich Village: Best for historic, intimate stays like The Marlton (bohemian-chic) or the Art Deco-inspired Walker Hotel.
  • SoHo & Nolita: Home to design-forward, trendy luxury. The Crosby Street Hotel is a colorful, whimsical favorite, while The Mercer offers classic loft-style living.
  • Lower East Side: Offers edgy, cool options like The Ludlow and the sophisticated, beautifully restored Nine Orchard in a former bank building.
  • Tribeca: Known for discreet, high-end boutique luxury, most notably Robert De Niro’s The Greenwich Hotel.
  • Chelsea & Meatpacking District: The legendary Hotel Chelsea has reopened and is the ultimate historic boutique stay. For modern design and party vibes, The Standard High Line is iconic.
  • Williamsburg (Brooklyn): The hub for hip, independent hotels with killer skyline views, including the factory-converted Wythe Hotel and The Hoxton.

7. Which NYC neighborhoods are best for nightlife?

  • Lower East Side & East Village: The epicenter of Manhattan nightlife. The East Village offers speakeasies, dive bars, and live indie music, while the Lower East Side is louder and younger, packed with crowded bars and late-night pizza spots.
  • Greenwich Village: A more historic, sophisticated vibe. This is the place for legendary jazz clubs (Village Vanguard, Blue Note), the best comedy clubs (Comedy Cellar), and historic literary pubs.
  • Meatpacking District: The destination for “models and bottles.” Expect strict door policies, high-end clubs, expensive cocktails, and chic rooftop bars like RH Rooftop or the Standard.
  • Williamsburg & Bushwick (Brooklyn): Williamsburg has matured into a polished scene of hotel rooftop bars and breweries. For serious clubbing, warehouse parties, and electronic music, head deeper into Bushwick (home to House of Yes).
  • Hell’s Kitchen: A much better option than Times Square for nightlife in Midtown. It features a massive, vibrant LGBTQ+ bar scene along 9th and 10th Avenues and offers great pre- and post-theater energy without the tourist traps.
Hotel near Highline in Chelsea.

The start of the High Line, steps from one of my favorite hotels, the Pendry Manhattan West.

8. Where to stay in NYC for a local experience?

  • To feel like a New Yorker, move away from the high-rise hotels of Midtown and choose a neighborhood with independent businesses and active street life. Note: With the ban on most apartment rentals, you will need to find specific boutique hotels in these areas to stay legally.
  • Brownstone Brooklyn: Neighborhoods like Park Slope, Carroll Gardens, and Fort Greene offer the quintessential tree-lined, residential lifestyle. You’ll find incredible coffee shops, local farmers markets, and a relaxed pace. Since hotels are rare deep in these neighborhoods, look at the Ace Hotel Brooklyn (Boerum Hill) or Hotel Le Bleu (Park Slope) to be close to the action.
  • Upper West Side: This neighborhood maintains a classic, cultured New York feel. Shop at local institutions like Zabar’s, grab a bagel, and join the locals for a walk in Riverside Park. It stays busy with residents rather than tour groups.
  • Greenwich Village / West Village: While popular with tourists, these neighborhoods have a fiercely protected local character. The winding side streets are home to long-term residents and independent bookstores. It feels like a small village inside the big city.
  • Harlem: A neighborhood rich in history and soul. Staying here offers an authentic experience, from the historic brownstones of Mount Morris Park to the incredible jazz clubs and soul food at Sylvia’s or Red Rooster.

9. What neighborhoods offer the best food scenes?

  • Greenwich Village & West Village: The gold standard for “date night” dining. This area blends legendary pizzerias (Joe’s, John’s of Bleecker) with high-end, Michelin-starred bistros in a charming, historic setting.
  • East Village & Lower East Side: The hub for creative, affordable, and diverse eats. It is famous for “Little Tokyo,” late-night slices, and an endless variety of vegan and experimental spots.
  • Chinatown & Flushing: For Manhattan convenience, Chinatown offers unbeatable value and dim sum. For the serious food adventurer, Flushing, Queens (specifically the food malls near the Main St subway station) offers the most authentic and varied Asian cuisine in the city.
  • Williamsburg: A powerhouse of trendy, chef-driven restaurants and artisanal bakeries. It hosts Smorgasburg, the massive outdoor food market, every Saturday on the waterfront.
  • Jackson Heights: The most diverse neighborhood in NYC. Head here for authentic Himalayan momos, Indian curries, and Latin American street food.

10. What are the best areas for shopping?

  • SoHo & Nolita: The city’s most popular fashion district. SoHo features massive flagships (Nike, Zara) and designer lofts, while neighboring Nolita offers a quieter mix of independent boutiques and curated shops.
  • Fifth Avenue & Madison Avenue: The traditional home of luxury. Walk Fifth Avenue (49th to 60th Sts) for iconic department stores like Bergdorf Goodman and the new Tiffany & Co. Landmark.
  • Hudson Yards: A sleek, high-end indoor mall experience on the West Side. It offers many of the same luxury brands as Fifth Avenue but in a modern, climate-controlled complex.
  • East Village & Williamsburg: The best destinations for vintage, thrift, and “cool” independent makers.
  • Herald Square: Anchored by the massive Macy’s flagship, this is the hub for mid-market brands and fast fashion – but expect heavy crowds.
Me and my family in New York City.

My family and I in New York City.

11. What are the best neighborhoods in NYC for families with kids?

  • The Strategy: Look for safety, proximity to parks, and most importantly, space. With strict bans on short-term apartment rentals, finding a hotel with suites or kitchenettes is the key to family sanity.
  • Upper West Side: My #1 pick. It is residential, safe, and sandwiched between two massive parks (Central Park and Riverside Park). You are steps from the American Museum of Natural History. Stay: Hotel Beacon is the gold standard (spacious suites with kitchenettes and laundry), or the stylish Arthouse Hotel.
  • Midtown: Best if you prioritize being steps from Broadway or Times Square over quiet nights. Stay: Radio City Apartments is the best value find (older but clean apartments with full kitchens). Marriott Marquis is a machine for families, and The Peninsula has a fantastic indoor pool.
  • Financial District: Quiet at night and packed with history. Stay: Mint House at 70 Pine is a stunning Art Deco building with huge apartment-style units and a grocery store in the basement. Conrad New York Downtown is a luxury all-suite option near the ferry terminal.
  • Upper East Side: Extremely safe and home to Museum Mile (The Met, Guggenheim). Stay: The Gardens Sonesta ES Suites features full kitchens and massive rooms.
  • Brooklyn (Boerum Hill & Dumbo): While families love visiting Park Slope, it has very few good hotels. Stay in nearby Boerum Hill or Dumbo instead for better access. Stay: Ace Hotel Brooklyn (cool, central, very near Park Slope) or 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge (luxury on the waterfront with a pool).
Hotel near Hudson Yards, Edge, and the Vessel.

The 5-star Equinox Hotel, located across from the Edge (outdoor viewing deck), Hudson Yards (a high end indoor mall), and a subway station.

12. What are the best neighborhoods for couples?

  • The Strategy: For the most romantic experience, choose a neighborhood with historic charm, cobblestone streets, and intimate dining rather than the high-rise chaos of Midtown.
  • Greenwich Village & West Village: The most romantic area in the city. It features leafy streets, ivy-covered brownstones, and intimate jazz clubs. Ideal for wandering and “date night” dining. Stay: The Marlton (bohemian-chic luxury) or Walker Hotel (Art Deco charm).
  • SoHo: Perfect for couples who want a trendy, high-fashion atmosphere. The cast-iron architecture and hidden loft bars create a very stylish mood. Stay: Crosby Street Hotel (vibrant design and a private courtyard) or The Mercer.
  • Upper East Side: Best for “Old New York” elegance and quiet luxury. It offers immediate access to the most scenic parts of Central Park. Stay: The Lowell (the only NYC hotel with authentic wood-burning fireplaces in-room) or the timeless The Carlyle.
  • Brooklyn Heights & Dumbo: The top spot for iconic views. You are right on the waterfront with the Manhattan skyline and Brooklyn Bridge as your backdrop. Stay: 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge – the rooftop pool and floor-to-ceiling skyline views are unbeatable.
  • Tribeca: A sophisticated, low-key alternative to SoHo. It’s home to some of the city’s best fine-dining restaurants and feels very private. Stay: The Greenwich Hotel (features a stunning underground pool and spa).

13. What are the best neighborhoods for solo travelers?

  • The Strategy: Choose neighborhoods with active street life and a strong culture of “dining at the bar,” which makes eating alone feel natural and social. Safety is also a priority.
  • Greenwich Village & East Village: Best for a social atmosphere. These areas are packed with cafes, dive bars, and restaurants where dining solo is the norm. It is the easiest place to blend in. Stay: Moxy East Village (fun, youthful, and designed for socializing) or The Marlton (great lobby bar).
  • Upper West Side: The most secure-feeling base. Excellent for solo female travelers who want proximity to Central Park and a quieter environment that feels like a real neighborhood. Stay: HI New York City is a reputable, safe hostel here.
  • Williamsburg (Brooklyn): Great for younger solos seeking a trendy nightlife scene and high-end coffee shops. It feels less anonymous than Midtown. Stay: Pod Brooklyn offers efficient, affordable solo rooms right in the center of the action.
  • Micro-Hotels & Social Hubs: NYC has a specific category of hotels with tiny rooms but massive, vibrant common areas designed for meeting people. Stay: Arlo NoMad (famous for its “micro” rooms and rooftop bar), Freehand New York (Flatiron), or citizenM (multiple locations).

14. What is a realistic budget for a hotel in NYC?

  • The Reality: NYC is one of the most expensive hotel markets in the world. Prices are dynamic and spike dramatically during the Holidays (December), May, September, and during the NYC Marathon (November).
  • Budget ($150 – $275): True “budget” hotels in Manhattan are rare. This price range usually gets you a bunk in a hostel, a “pod” hotel with a shared bath, or a standard chain hotel in Long Island City (Queens).
  • Mid-Range Manhattan ($300 – $650): This is the standard rate for a typical Queen room in a Marriott/Hilton/Hyatt in Midtown. Expect to pay the higher end of this range in Spring and Fall.
  • Luxury ($850 – $2,000+): For 5-star properties like The Pierre, Mandarin Oriental, or The Carlyle, rates start high and skyrocket for suites.
  • The “Hidden” Costs: You must budget for taxes and fees. New York adds 14.75% + $3.50 per night in taxes to the bill. Additionally, many hotels charge a mandatory “Destination Fee” or “Facility Fee” of $30–$50 per night that is rarely included in the initial search price.
The historic White Horse Tavern in Greenwich Village in New York City.

The historic White Horse Tavern in Greenwich Village.

15. Is it worth staying in Queens or New Jersey to save money?

  • The Short Answer: If you are on a strict budget, yes – but choose your location carefully. If you have a short trip (3 days or less), stay in Manhattan. The time and energy you waste commuting isn’t worth the $50/night savings.
  • Long Island City (Queens): This is the #1 value alternative. It is not charming, but it is safe, modern, and extremely close. You can find clean hotels for 30–40% less than Midtown, and you are often only one subway stop (7 minutes) from Grand Central.
  • Brooklyn: Do not assume Brooklyn is cheaper. Trendy areas like Williamsburg and Dumbo are often more expensive than Midtown. For real savings, you have to look much further out (like Sunset Park), which means a 40+ minute commute.
  • New Jersey (Jersey City/Hoboken): You can find larger rooms and skyline views here for less money. The Catch: You must take the PATH train or a ferry to cross the river. The PATH requires a separate fare from the NYC subway, so you end up paying double for transit every day. It also stops running frequently late at night, which kills the vibe if you want to enjoy NYC nightlife.

16. How far in advance should I book my NYC hotel?

  • The Golden Rule: Book as soon as your dates are firm. NYC is a high-demand market, and the ban on Airbnb has put even more pressure on hotel inventory. Last-minute “deals” are extremely rare and usually only exist at the least desirable properties.
  • Peak Seasons (May, June, September, October, December): Book 4 to 6 months in advance. October and December are often the most expensive months of the year; the best-value rooms will be gone if you wait.
  • Major Events: If your trip coincides with the NYC Marathon (first Sunday in November), the US Open (late August/early September), or New Year’s Eve, book 9 to 12 months out.
  • Off-Season (January to early March): This is the only time you might find flexibility. You can often find decent rates 4 to 6 weeks out.
  • Pro Tip: Book a refundable rate 6-9 months in advance to lock in a price. Check back 4 weeks before your trip; if prices have dropped (unlikely, but possible in winter), you can rebook and save.

17. How close to a subway station should I stay?

  • The Golden Rule: Your hotel should be within a 5-minute walk (roughly 2-3 avenues or 5 street blocks) of a subway entrance. This is the single most important factor for an efficient trip.
  • Why it matters: You will likely walk 5 to 10 miles a day while sightseeing. If your hotel is a “15-minute walk” from the subway, that adds 30 minutes of unnecessary walking just to start and end your day. Trust me: your feet will regret it.
  • Level Up: Not all stations are created equal. Ideally, choose a hotel near a Major Hub (like 42nd St, 14th St-Union Square, or Fulton St) or an Express Stop. Having access to multiple subway lines prevents you from being stranded if one line has weekend construction delays.
Streetside produce stalls in Chinatown neighborhood of New York City.

Streetside produce stalls in Chinatown.

18. Are there resort fees or hidden hotel taxes in NYC?

  • Yes, and they are significant. When budgeting, you must look beyond the advertised nightly rate.
  • The Taxes: Expect to pay 14.75% (combined city and state tax) plus ~$3.50 per night in occupancy fees on top of your room rate.
  • The “Destination” Fee: Many hotels – even budget and mid-range chains – now add a mandatory “Facility Fee,” “Destination Fee,” or “Urban Fee.” This is typically $30 to $50 per night. It supposedly covers Wi-Fi and gym access, but you have to pay it whether you use them or not.
  • The Trap: These fees are rarely included in the initial bold price you see on search engines. Always click through to the final checkout screen to see the true total.

19. What is the best area to stay for a Broadway trip?

  • The Strategy: Stay within walking distance. The vast majority of Broadway theaters are clustered between 41st and 54th Streets, from 6th to 8th Avenues.
  • Why walkability matters: When shows let out around 10:30 PM, the streets are flooded with people. Hailing a taxi is nearly impossible, Uber surge pricing skyrockets, and subway platforms are packed. Being able to walk 5–10 minutes back to your hotel is the ultimate luxury.
  • The “Pro” Move: Stay in Hell’s Kitchen (just west of 8th Ave). It is arguably the best base for theatergoers. You are a 5-minute walk from the theater doors, but you get a “real” neighborhood vibe, better dining (especially on 9th Ave), and a break from the neon chaos of Times Square.
  • The “Classic” Move: If you want to be in the middle of it all, stay in the Theater District or Times Square proper. Just be prepared for crowds the moment you step out your door.

20. Is Airbnb legal in New York City?

  • The Short Answer: For most tourists, no. Since September 2023, New York City has aggressively enforced Local Law 18, which effectively bans the short-term rental of entire apartments.
  • The Rules: It is illegal to rent an entire apartment for less than 30 days. You can only legally book a short-term rental if the host is present in the apartment with you during your stay (a “shared room” scenario) and no more than two guests are booked.
  • The Risk: Do not try to skirt this rule. Illegal listings are frequently flagged and cancelled by the platforms at the last minute, leaving travelers stranded.
  • The Alternatives: If you need a kitchen or extra space for a family, book a legal apartment-style hotel. Excellent, legal options include AKA, Mint House, Radio City Apartments, and Sonder properties.

21. Is New York City accessible for travelers with mobility issues?

  • The Reality: NYC is challenging. It is an old city, and much of the infrastructure lags behind modern accessibility standards.
  • Subway Warning: The subway is the biggest hurdle. Only about 30% of stations have elevators, and they are prone to service outages. You must check the official MTA Accessible Stations Map and elevator status in real-time before every trip.
  • Use the Bus: This is often the better option. 100% of NYC buses are accessible, featuring ramps and designated securement areas for wheelchairs.
  • Taxis & Rideshare: Roughly 50% of yellow taxis are wheelchair accessible (look for the symbol on the hood). UberWAV and Lyft Access are reliable and widely available throughout the five boroughs.
  • Neighborhoods: Be cautious in historic areas like SoHo, Tribeca, and the West Village. Cobblestone streets are difficult to navigate, and many older buildings (including restaurants and boutiques) have steps at the entrance.
  • Hotels: Newer hotels in Midtown, Hudson Yards, and the Financial District are almost universally ADA compliant. Always call ahead to confirm elevator dimensions if staying in a boutique hotel in an older building.

22. Are the NYC attraction passes (CityPASS, New York Pass) worth it?

  • The Short Answer: Only if you plan to visit 3+ major paid attractions (like the Empire State Building, Statue of Liberty, and 9/11 Museum) in a short time.
  • Do the Math: Don’t blindly buy a pass. Compare the cost of the specific sights you want to see against the pass price. Often, buying individual tickets allows for more flexibility and less “rush” to get your money’s worth.
  • The Main Options: The most popular are the New York CityPASS (best for first-timers hitting the top 5 icons), Go City Explorer Pass (pick a specific number of attractions), and The New York Pass (unlimited sights for a set number of days).

Getting Into and Around New York

Grand Central Station in Midtown Manhattan.

Grand Central Station.

How to Pay for Transit (The OMNY System)

  • Forget the MetroCard: You no longer need to buy a physical card. While MetroCards are still available at machines for now, the OMNY contactless system is the preferred and easiest way to pay.
  • Just Tap and Go: Simply tap your contactless credit card, debit card, or smartphone (Apple Pay/Google Pay) on the reader at any subway turnstile or bus boarding door. If the screen turns green and beeps, you’re good – no receipt needed.
  • The “Per Person” Rule: Each rider must use their own payment method to get free transfers. If you tap the same card twice for two people, you are charged two full fares, and the free transfer benefit only applies to the first person.
  • Fare Capping: If you ride more than 12 times in a seven-day period (Monday to Sunday) using the same device or card, you hit the cap. All subsequent rides that week are free. This effectively guarantees you never pay more than the cost of a 7-Day Unlimited Pass.

Navigating the City

  • The Grid: Above 14th Street, Manhattan is mostly a logical grid. Avenues run North-South and Streets run East-West. The Exception: Lower Manhattan (below Houston St) breaks the grid entirely. Expect angled streets, names instead of numbers, and irregular blocks. Use a map app here.
  • Uptown vs. Downtown: This confuses many first-timers. Uptown means traveling North (towards higher numbered streets, e.g., from 42nd St to 59th St). Downtown means traveling South (towards lower numbered streets, e.g., from 42nd St to 14th St).
  • Crosstown: This means moving East or West. The #7 Train (Queens-Manhattan) and L Train (Brooklyn-Manhattan) are the main crosstown subway options. Crosstown buses on major streets like 14th, 23rd, 34th, and 42nd are often faster and easier than the subway for short east-west trips. Be careful – avenue blocks are long. Walking from 1st Ave to 8th Ave takes about 20–25 minutes.
  • Express vs. Local: “Express” trains skip many stops; “Local” trains stop at every single station. Map Tip: On subway maps, Express stops are shown with white dots; Local-only stops are shown with black dots. Weekend Warning: Late nights and weekends, express trains often run local due to construction. Always check service notices posted in the station.
  • Apps: Download Citymapper or Google Maps for real-time routing. They are essential for navigating service changes.

Times Square subway hub connecting A/C/E, 1/2/3, N/Q/R/W lines.

Hotels within steps of major subway hubs

Getting into Manhattan from the Airports

Important Rules for All Airports

  • Do Not Rent a Car: Driving in Manhattan is stressful, slow, and expensive. Parking at a hotel can cost $70+ per night.
  • Ignore the Touts: Inside the arrivals terminal, aggressive drivers may approach you asking if you need a ride. Ignore them. These are illegal, unlicensed drivers who will overcharge you. Only take a yellow taxi from the official dispatch line or an Uber/Lyft booked through the app.

1. JFK International Airport (JFK)

Located in Queens, roughly 15 miles from Midtown.

  • Taxi (Easiest): Taxis charge a Flat Fare of $70. However, this excludes tolls, peak-hour surcharges, taxes, and tip. Most travelers pay $100–$110 all-in. Travel time: 60–90 minutes.
  • Uber / Lyft: Prices vary by demand but are usually comparable to or slightly higher than taxis ($85–$120).
  • Train (Fastest to Midtown): Take the AirTrain (red line) to Jamaica Station. Transfer to the LIRR (Long Island Rail Road). Take the train to New York Penn Station (West Side/Times Square) or Grand Central Madison (East Side). Cost: ~$8.50 for AirTrain + ~$5.00–$14.00 for LIRR ticket (higher fares apply during weekday rush hours). Travel time: ~45–60 minutes.
  • Subway (Cheapest): Take the AirTrain to Jamaica Station (Line E, J, Z) or Howard Beach (Line A). Cost: $11.40 total. Note: This is slow (60–90 mins) and many stations lack elevators. Hauling luggage up subway stairs is difficult; take the LIRR if you have heavy bags.

2. Newark Liberty International Airport (EWR)

Located in New Jersey, roughly 16 miles from Midtown.

  • Taxi: You will see NYC yellow taxis here, but they follow New Jersey pricing rules (often a flat rate based on destination zone plus surcharges). Expect to pay $85–$110 (including tolls and tip) to reach Midtown.
  • Train (Best Value): Take the AirTrain to the “Newark Liberty Airport Train Station.” From there, take a NJ Transit train to New York Penn Station in Manhattan (the last stop). Warning: Do NOT get off at “Newark Penn Station.” Cost: ~$16.00 one-way (adult). Time: ~45 minutes total.
  • Airport Bus: The Newark Airport Express bus runs to Port Authority, Bryant Park, and Grand Central. It costs roughly $19 one-way. Comfortable, but subject to tunnel traffic.

3. LaGuardia Airport (LGA)

Located in Queens, only 8 miles from Midtown. No direct train service.

  • Taxi (Best Option): Because LGA is physically closest to Manhattan, taxis are often the best choice. Rides are metered. Expect to pay $45–$65 total. Note: Prices spike during weekday rush hours and bad weather.
  • Uber / Lyft: Widely available. Follow signs for “App-Based Ride Service” pickup areas.
  • The “Free” Bus Link: The LaGuardia Link Q70-SBS is a free, luggage-friendly bus that loops non-stop between terminals and the Jackson Heights-Roosevelt Av subway station. It connects you to express subways (E, F) that get you to Midtown in 20 minutes, or the Woodside LIRR station for a fast train to Penn/Grand Central. Total cost is just the subway/rail fare.

New York Airport Hotels

  • JFK: The TWA Hotel is the only on-airport hotel. It is a stunning, retro-futuristic conversion of the old TWA flight center. Highly recommended for a layover.
  • LaGuardia: The Aloft and LaGuardia Plaza are decent options just a short shuttle ride away.
  • Newark: The Newark Liberty Marriott is the only hotel located centrally on airport grounds.

  1. Stay In Brooklyn or Manhattan?

    We are considering staying in Brooklyn to save money on a cheap hotel. Is this worth the money? Is it easy to commute from Brooklyn to Manhattan for sightseeing in NYC?

    1. Santorini Dave The Hotel Expert

      Brooklyn has some great areas and is a destination in its own right but (for most people) Manhattan is what they’re here to see and makes the best base for sightseeing. The big considerations are where in Brooklyn are you staying, how close is it to a subway stop, and how much money are you saving? If you are near a subway stop then getting into Manhattan will be quick and easy.

  2. NYC Interconnected Rooms for Family

    We are a family of 4 with two teens. Going to NYC for 1st time in October. Please can you advise on how to find a hotel that has interconnecting rooms. Need main room with double bed and connecting room with 2 separate beds. All searches so far come up with 2 doubles. Or would we need to have 2 seperate rooms? Thank you.

    1. Santorini Dave The Hotel Expert

      Interconnected rooms are rare. Take a look at the AKA Times Square. I’ve stayed here a few times. It has a great location and the 2-bedroom apartments with kitchens are perfect for families.

  3. Hotel in NYC for 3 Adults

    Hihi,

    Will be travelling to New York this December for Christmas and New Year for Times Square. But the hotels near Times Square are so pricey. Would you help to recommend the good place to stay for a group of 3?

    1. Santorini Dave The Hotel Expert

      I suggest the Freehand Hotel in Midtown. It has cozy 3-bed and 4-bed rooms that are great value. (Some have boutique-style bunk beds.)

  4. Airbnb for Family of 5 in NYC

    Would you recommend Airbnb for Manhattan/Brooklyn? We are a family of 5 so apartment may suit us better and the AKA apartments you recommended have only 2 beds. I’ve heard that some Airbnb are not legal within NYC.

    Thanks

    1. Santorini Dave The Hotel Expert

      I love the two-bedroom apartments at AKA and they do sleep five. Airbnb in New York City is a possibility but is very hit and miss. I’d stick with the hotel.

  5. Best Hostel in New York City

    Hey! Thank you for posting all this amazing info. I am traveling solo to NYC for the first time and was thinking of staying in a hostel. What are your thoughts?

    1. Santorini Dave The Hotel Expert

      The HI NYC Hostel is the best hostel in NYC but it’s a little out of the way on the Upper West Side. Instead I’d recommend the Historical Blue Moon Hotel on the Lower East Side. It’s better located for bars, restaurants, and nightlife and almost as good.

  6. Staying in New Jersey for NYC Visit

    First time in New York and staying at Homewood Suites by Hilton Edgewater NYC. Would like to know if this hotel is safe and can give us easy access to most tourist attractions like Times Square and the Statue of Liberty?

    1. Santorini Dave The Hotel Expert

      The hotel offers a free shuttle to the ferry terminal on the New Jersey side, then you take a ferry to Manhattan ($9, each way), and then another free shuttle to get you to a few different popular spots in the city. I wouldn’t call it convenient, but not terrible either.

  7. AirBnb or Hotel in NYC for Large Group

    Hi, traveling to NYC in April for the first time with families totaling 11 (age ranging from 3 to 79!). What sort of accommodation is best recommended for our group size – Airbnb or hotel, that are both clean, close to attractions and not cost us an arm. Thanks in advance for your guidance!

    1. Santorini Dave The Hotel Expert

      I think I would go with several rooms in a moderate hotel. Unless you can find an Airbnb for a large group – possible but not easy.

  8. New York for 3rd Time

    Loved this post! I’ve been to NYC a few times but always struggle to decide where to stay. You’ve given me some great ideas for my next trip – I think I’ll have to try the West Village this time!

    1. Santorini Dave The Hotel Expert

      I love hearing that our stuff has been helpful. That’s our goal. Thank you.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *